LCW Critique Groups

Welcome to the Louisville Christian Writers' critique group information page.  We have organized this like a frequently asked questions (FAQ) page, and hopefully it will answer any questions you may have about participation in critique groups.

What is a critique group?

A critique group within Louisville Christian Writers is generally a small group of fellow writers (3 to 5 on average) with whom each writer who has brought a piece shares his or her writing and requests feedback. 

Are critique groups for members only?

Members have priority to have their work read and reviewed first, but new visitors and invited guests are also able to participate. Non-Members and guests are welcomed and encouraged to share their thoughts on the works being presented for critique, and they will be given the opportunity to present their own written works for critique if time allows. Please see the rules below for guidelines that will make participation in critique groups achieve the most value for both writers and readers.

Why are critique groups so important to the individual writer?

Allowing other writers to read your writing before you submit it for publication, even to a non-paid source like our semi-annual newsletter, helps you as a writer to perfect the gift God has given you.  There may be items within your writing, (errors, plot holes, or even just ideas which could be presented more clearly with a bit of rewording), that you may not see as well because you are too close to it. By having one or more other writers look at it from an editorial perspective, you get to see first hand the effect your writing has on readers, especially the effect it might have on a professional editor or publisher.  It is an exercise of growth that should ultimately strengthen your writing and help you become better prepared for publication.

As a reader, your critique group also helps you in your ability to read and absorb what you are reading, as well as strengthening your own editing abilities.  Self-editing is very important in today's market as a well-edited piece of writing will put your writing ahead of much of the competition.

Are there rules in the LCW critique groups?

It is very important for writers to learn to perfect their talents, but it is also important for them to receive encouragement, so we provide guidelines for participating in a critique group that should help both to be accomplished.  Some of those rules follow ...

• Manuscripts must be no longer than 4 typewritten and double-spaced pages to allow time for all group members to participate.  Longer manuscripts can be broken down so groups can eventually read them at length, however, it is recommended that writers with longer manuscripts find someone whose critiques they value and ask to work with that person as a critique partner between meetings.
• Writers may submit any kind of writing: articles, stories, poetry, lyrics, etc., as long as it does not exceed the length requirement.
• Writers should make sure their works have had basic grammar and spell-checking done on them if possible.  This is a courtesy to those who will be reading, and a necessity if the writer plans on submitting his or her manuscript for publication.  If the writer does not own a computer, it is recommended that he or she go to the public library to type the submission and use the computer spell-checker.  Most public libraries even have free classes on using the computers and programs necessary for writers.
• As one receiving a critique, a writer should be prepared to feel criticized because it's a natural defense when someone is examining his or her "baby".  But, the writer should also be open to receiving the corrections and suggestions of others in spite of the natural inclination to resist change.
• As one giving a critique, a writer (especially a Christian writer) should remember to be gentle and to stand on the "golden rule".  First, give encouragement by telling the author what you like or value in his or her piece. Then, without trying to change the author's natural voice, state what items you feel could or should be changed to bring out the best in the writing. Critique as one looking to find value in the writing and bring it out as a treasure to shine brightly for everyone else to see. Remember that honesty is important, but it has also been said that honesty without compassion is cruelty.

If you still have questions after reading this information, please e-mail us by clicking the link near the bottom of the home page.